One Story, Two Perspectives…
I was watching FOX News this evening and a feature caught my attention which I thought was blog-worthy, so here goes…
The difference between the press in Great Britain and America interests me greatly. Two allied countries, which are both English speaking, can have radically different views on certain topics, and notably different ways that these views are reported. I’m not going to pretend that I’m an expert on American news. If I’m honest, I really don’t know that much about it at all, particularly in depth in comparison to Britain, but there are some obvious differences that can be observed just from watching for a short period of time.
However, it was on The O’Reilly Factor show on FOX News tonight that actually compared how one particular story was reported on ABC and NBC news channels. This story is about the murder of Trayvon Martin, a 17-year old teenager, who was killed at the NBA All Star Game in Sanford, Florida on 26th February. George Zimmerman has been charged with second degree murder.
It was said on this show, and is worth noting, that in Great Britain the court can prevent certain stories from being reported on for fear of “tainting” them. However, the Zimmerman trial has been heavily reported both on ABC and NBC, but very differently. Bill O’Reilly, the veteran journalist who anchors this FOX News programme, pointed out that 42 stories related to this trial have been reported by ABC since 10th March. The reporting has been very focused on the news story, with little commentary attached to it. Furthermore, ABC has published graphic images and evidence, which could be seen as controversial and perhaps not appropriate for such a wide audience.
On the contrary, NBC’s reporting has been very opinionated and one-sided towards the prosecution of George Zimmerman and the justice for Trayvon Martin. This is not to say that they should be defending the accused, but it’s clear to see they are explicitly and openly pushing Zimmerman’s prosecution and that ideology is dominating their angle of the story. In the words of Geraldo Rivera, an American talk show host and FOX News reporter, they are “cheerleading for [his] conviction”. It’s almost as if NBC are being accused for advocating rather than reporting.
Different media organisations in countries like Great Britain and America, whether on broadcast, print or online platforms, are not obliged to have the same political stance or opinions, therefore variations in reporting are inevitable. However, reporting on court cases can be a dangerous thing to do. Journalists can only report on what they have been told, and placing a firm opinion on certain issues can lead the public astray and perhaps cause inaccuracy within reporting.
O’Reilly ended the report emphasising that FOX News will “continue to cover the story without prejudice”.
It’s interesting how a story of a murder case can create such polarised angles…


